Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), which is an environmental benign oxidant, is widely applied in the textile, pulp/paper bleaching, waste water treatment, and pharmaceutical industries [1]. Currently, over three million metric tons of H2O2 are produced annually via the anthraquinone process, which involves sequential hydrogenation and oxidation of anthraquinone [1, 2]. However, there are concerns about the carbon efficiency of the process, not least of which is the unselective hydrogenation of anthraquinone that requires replenishment during the cycle. Moreover, the process inherently requires large capital and operating costs, because of the energy-intensive separation, concentration, and transportation of H2O2 [3]. From an economic and environmental point of view, the direct synthesis of H2O2 from H2 and O2 over a Pd-based catalyst is a promising, desirable, and atom-efficient route that provides an alternative to the current process. Direct synthesis avoids the use of expensive anthraquinone, the production of waste, and the complexity of purification. What is more, the coupling of direct, on-line H2O2 production with downstream oxidation is highly desirable in that it produces value-added products by shortening the supply chain [4-7].
Although direct synthesis has advantages over the existing process, its industrial implementation has been hindered by the limited selectivity and stability of supported Pd nanoparticles (NPs), which are the most active known catalysts [8]. It is known that apart from facilitating the selective oxidation of H2 to H2O2, monometallic Pd catalysts also promote the non-selective oxidation of H2 to water and the hydrogenation of H2O2. Several strategies have been employed to overcome this limitation by modifying the structure of Pd NPs: (1) tuning the Pd ensembles with supports [9-13], (2) altering their surface properties with ligands [14], and (3) alloying Pd with a second metal (e.g., Pt, Au, Sn, Zn) [15-19]. Pd-Au and Pd-Sn catalysts are the most selective catalysts operating at high pressure (4.0 MPa) to date. Our previous study of Pd-Au/TiO2 catalysts showed that Pd monomers surrounded by Au atoms can be primary active sites for H2O2 formation [17], in good agreement with theoretical calculations that O–O bond scission is suppressed over Pd-Au sites [20]. Maity et al. [21] demonstrated that bimetallic Ni-Pd catalysts in the presence of halide ions showed three times greater activities than monometallic Pd catalysts. In our recent work, initial H2O2 selectivities of more than 90% were obtained over Pd-Te/TiO2 and Pd/HAp catalysts at 283 K, 0.1 MPa. Even so, the activities and stability of these catalysts do not meet the requirements of commercial production [22, 23].
Sb has been shown to improve the performance of Pd catalysts [24] and can be alloyed with Pd [25, 26]. We report, herein, the promotional effects of Sb on Pd catalysts for H2O2 formation. A series of Pd-Sb/TiO2 catalysts with different Pd/Sb ratios were prepared and tested for direct H2O2 synthesis under ambient conditions. The nature of the active sites was examined thoroughly, and deep insight into the structure-performance behavior of the catalysts was obtained by multiple methods of characterization including transmission electron microscopy (TEM), X-ray diffraction (XRD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), in situ diffuse reflection infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy for CO adsorption (CO-DRIFTS), and temperature-programmed desorption of H2 and O2 (H2/O2-TPD).
Monometallic Pd and bimetallic Pd-Sb catalysts were prepared by an incipient wetness impregnating method as described in a previous study [27]. An aqueous solution of H2PdCl4 (Sigma-Aldrich) and SbCl3 (Aladdin, 99.9%) were used as the precursor. TiO2 (Degussa P25, 50 ± 15 m2/g) was adopted as the support. Pd-Sb catalysts with Sb/Pd atomic ratios of 0, 1/80, 1/50, 1/20, and 1/2 were prepared. Each catalyst had a 3 wt% Pd loading. Prior to reaction, all catalysts were calcined in static air at 773 K for 2 h and then reduced at 573 K in a 1:2 H2:N2 flow at 75 mL/min for 2 h at a ramp rate of 5 K/min. The resulting catalysts are denoted as PdxSb, where x is the molar ratio of Pd to Sb.
TEM measurements were performed on a JEOL JEM 2010F electron microscope at an operating voltage of 200 kV. The catalysts were ultrasonically suspended in ethanol. One drop of this slurry was deposited on a carbon-coated copper grid. The liquid phase was evaporated before loading the grid into the microscope. The size distribution of each sample was derived from the analysis of over 300 particles.
XRD powder patterns at ambient conditions were recorded using a Rigaku D/max 2550 diffractometer with an accelerator voltage of 40 kV and a detector current of 100 mA. Cu-Ka radiation was used for continuous scanning with a step-size of 0.02° over a 2q range of 10°–80° with a scan speed of 4°/min.
XPS analysis was performed on a Thermo ESCALAB 250Xi spectrometer using a monochromatic Al-Kαradiation source (1486.6 eV, pass energy 20.0 eV). The base pressure of the instrument was about 1 x 10-9 Torr. Binding energies (BEs) were calibrated using the C 1s peak at 284.8 eV as a reference. The Pd 3d peaks were fitted after Shirley background subtraction; the Pd 3d orbitals were described by two features in each state. A branching ratio of 1.5 for 3d5/2:3d3/2 and the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the Pd 3d peaks were held constant. The 3d3/2 and 3d5/2 peaks of Sb also were measured with the latter being overlapped by the O 1s transition. Linear background subtraction was used to fit the Sb 3d peaks. It is evident from the shape of the Sb 3d5/2 transitions that these BEs and those of O 1s are very close making deconvolution of the individual contributions difficult. Thus, we chose to constrain only the peak position based on the energy difference (9.35 eV) of the Sb 3d doublet. The Pd 3d, Sb 3d, and O 1s spectral features were fitted using a sum of Gaussian-Lorentzian distributions (SGL (20)).
In situ CO-DRIFTS was recorded on a Perkin-Elmer Spectrum 100 FT-IR spectrometer equipped with a reaction cell (modified Harricks Model HV-DR2) that allowed gas to flow continuously through the catalyst bed (ca. 0.1 g) during spectra acquisition. Before adsorption, the sample was reduced in situ and then cooled to 283 K in pure Ar. CO gas was introduced into the system for 30 min. The spectra were collected at 4 cm-1 resolution. The bridge-to linear-bound ratios reported here do not take into account the differences in extinction coefficient between adsorption sites. Therefore, the bridge-to linear-bound ratio does not represent quantitative coverages, but rather the qualitative differences between catalysts.
H2/O2-TPD experiments were performed using a U-tube connected to a GC-QMS (HPR-20, Hiden Analytical Ltd.), where masses of m/e = 2 (H2), 18 (H2O), 32 (O2), and 40 (Ar) were monitored. Prior to the adsorption, the catalysts were pretreated in static air at 773 K for 2 h, in H2/Ar at 573 K for 2 h, and then cooled in ultrapure Ar. H2/O2 adsorbate (20 mL/min, 30 min) was introduced into the system at 283 K. The system was purged with Ar (40 mL/min) until the H2/O2 signal reached a constant value. The temperature was ramped from 283 to 1073 K at a rate of 20 K/min in Ar (40 mL/min).
H2O2 synthesis and degradation activity were evaluated using a modified micro-triphase-semi-batch reactor at 283 K and atmospheric pressure. The reactor was charged with catalyst (0.05 g) and 60 mL of ethanol and 0.38 mL of concentrated H2SO4 as reaction solvent to test the H2O2 synthesis. The reagent gases (15 vol% H2, 60 vol% O2, 25 vol% N2, 60 mL/min total flowrate) were introduced to the reactor through a premixer and fine glass frit in sequence with Teflon-rotor magnetic stirring at 1000 r/min. H2 conversion was analyzed by gas chromatography, and H2O2 production was determined by UV/vis spectrophotometry after complexation with a TiOSO4/H2SO4 reagent. H2O2 selectivity (SH2O2) was determined from the rate of H2O2 formation and the rate of H2 conversion using the equation
H2O2 decomposition and hydrogenation experiments were carried out in a manner similar to the H2O2 synthesis, but in the absence of O2. The initial H2O2 concentration was 0.3 wt%. The reaction was conducted for 1 h with the concentration of H2O2 determined every 10 min.
The performance of the Pd-Sb catalysts is summarized in Table 1 and compared with those of typical catalysts reported in the literature (Table S1). The synthesis of H2O2 and its hydrogenation/decomposition reactions take place simultaneously. Thus, productivity is the sum of all these processes [28]. A H2 conversion of 29.5% and a H2O2 selectivity of 54% was observed with monometallic Pd. Upon addition of Sb, selectivity increases to 68% for Pd80Sb. A uniquely high H2O2 selectivity of 73% corresponding to a H2O2 productivity of 1552 mol H2O2/kgPd/h was found for Pd50Sb. The activities and selectivities of the catalysts decline at Pd/Sb = 20, and the catalyst with a Pd/Sb ratio of 2 is inactive.
To understand the promotional effects of Sb, the H2O2 decomposition and hydrogenation side reactions must be taken into account. For H2O2 decomposition, H2O2 consumption was negligible over all catalysts under N2 flow. In contrast, H2O2 conversion was observed under H2 flow. We conclude that H2O2 hydrogenation is the main pathway for subsequent H2O2 conversion, which lowers the selectivity (Fig. 1). Monometallic Pd showed the greatest H2O2 hydrogenation activity with a rate of 2678 mol H2O2/kgPd/h (Table 1). The hydrogenation rate declined with increasing Sb concentration. Pd2Sb exhibited the lowest hydrogenation activity. These results indicate that addition of Sb blocks H2O2 hydrogenation. However, Pd2Sb showed little H2 conversion activity despite its low H2O2 hydrogenation activity. This might result from the absence of active sites on the catalyst surface at large Sb loading. The dependence of catalytic performance on Sb loading suggests that variation of the Pd/Sb atomic ratio finely tunes the electronic and geometric structures of Pd-Sb catalysts. To unveil the mechanism of active sites formation, the catalysts were systematically characterized.
Fig. 2 displays typical TEM images and particle size distributions of the fresh catalysts. Compared to Pd50Sb, monometallic Pd exhibits a broad particle size distribution and an average size of ca. 3.2 nm (Fig. 2(c)). The lattice fringes with a 0.24-nm spacing corresponding to the Pd(111) plane are clearly visible in the HRTEM images. The mean particle diameter decreases to ca. 1.8 nm (Fig. 2(d)) for Pd50Sb, suggesting that the addition of Sb significantly promotes dispersion of the Pd particles.
XRD patterns (Fig. 3) show that TiO2 (Degussa P25) is composed of two phases, anatase and rutile, even after loading Pd. Almost no crystalline Pd was detected, except that a small peak at 40.4°, which was assigned to the Pd(111) plane, was observed for some catalysts. When the Pd:Sb ratio decreased to 2:1, the 40.4° peak vanished. The results indicate that Pd-Sb catalysts comprise mainly small metal particles (< 4.0 nm), which are beyond the detection limit of XRD. The conclusion is consistent with TEM results [29].
The chemical nature of the catalyst surface, in particular the Pd2+/Pd0 ratio, is crucial to H2O2 selectivity [11, 30]. Thus, XPS analysis was performed to examine the electronic interactions between Pd and Sb and the valence state of Pd surface species. The Pd 3d core-level spectra for all catalysts are displayed in Fig. 4, and results are summarized in Table 2. Peaks with binding energies of 334.9 and 340.3 eV are attributed to Pd0 3d5/2 and 3d3/2, respectively [31, 32], while those at 341.3 and 336.0 eV are assigned to Pd2+ 3d5/2 and 3d3/2 [33, 34]. Pd0 and Pd2+ were detected in all catalysts, and the Pd0/Pd2+ ratio increased from 58.4/41.6 in Pd to 77.1/22.9 in Pd2Sb. Thus, addition of Sb inhibited the oxidation of metallic Pd. Our previous study detected only metallic Pd0 for Pd/SiO2 [35], which indicates that formation of Pd2+ species might result from interaction between Pd particles and TiO2 [17, 27].
Chemical states in the Sb 3d XPS spectrum (Fig. 5(a)) are difficult to identify by deconvoluting the individual contributions due to overlap of the Sb 3d5/2 and O 1s core levels. Because of the low Sb concentration, almost no Sb peaks are observed apart from a distinguishable one at 539.5 eV for Pd2Sb. The 539.5 and 530.1 eV peaks are attributed to Sb3+ 3d3/2 and 3d5/2 (Fig. 5(b)), respectively. The atomic ratio of Sb/Pd on the surface of Pd2Sb is 9/10 based on the relative sensitivity factor (RSF) (Pd: 39.787, Sb: 19.353) and their signal intensity, which is markedly greater than the bulk Sb/Pd ratio in the catalyst. This suggests that an Sb2O3 layer forms on and covers the Pd surface of Pd-Sb catalysts with a large Sb content [36, 37]. Because of the encapsulating Sb2O3 layer on the catalyst surface, H2 and O2 activation is hindered rendering Pd2Sb inert in this reaction. A decrease in exposed Pd area also was detected by CO pulse chemisorption (Table S2), which further suggests the encapsulation of Pd particles by Sb. BEs of 531.7, 530.3, and 529.8 eV in the O 1s core-level spectra are attributed, respectively to the following oxygen species: (1) the oxygen of surface hydroxyl groups or carbonate species formed by exposing the sample to air [38], (2) the lattice oxygen of TiO2, and (3) oxygen adsorbed on the surface of PdO/SbOx particles [39].
The spectra of adsorbed CO (Fig. 6) show absorption bands of CO (v(CO)) at 2078, 1982, and 1923 cm-1 for the monometallic Pd catalyst [40, 41]. The peak at 2078 cm-1 represents linearly bonded CO (Pd-CO) at the small population of Pd atoms that are located at corner or edge positions on Pd particles. The bands at 1700–2010 cm-1 are assigned to bridging and multiply bonded CO on Pd ensembles comprising two or three contiguous Pd atoms [42, 43]. With the incorporation of Sb, the ratio of bridging and multiply bonded CO to linearly bonded CO increases gradually (Table 3). This suggests that the concentration of small Pd clusters increase with increasing Sb content leading to an increase in the number of low-coordinated Pd sites at the corners and edges. For Pd2Sb, only linearly bonded CO is observed indicating that only highly dispersed clusters or isolated Pd atoms are formed. The results indicate that the proportion of contiguous Pd surface sites decreases and the number of single Pd sites increases due to the dilution effect of Sb. This change is responsible for the geometric effect produced by changing the relative Pd and Sb contents. A red shift of bridging CO bands from 1982 to 1969 cm-1 is observed in the presence of Sb. It is attributed to enhancement of the d-orbital electron density of Pd by charge-transfer from Sb to Pd, which produces strong electron back-donation to the 2π* molecular orbitals of CO [44]. A similar phenomenon has been observed for Pd-Au/TiO2 (SiO2) catalysts [17, 35].
Since the catalysts were under an O2-rich circumstance in the reaction, herein the effect of O2 on Pd surface was investigated by pretreating the samples with O2 for 30 min following the reduction process. Compared to the samples without O2 pretreatment (Fig. 6), the relative intensities of peaks for O2 pretreated catalysts changed remarkably, and a new peak at 2123 cm–1 was observed for Pd50Sb and Pd20Sb (Fig. 7). The changes in the peak positions and intensities probably stem from the geometric and electronic modification of Pd atoms with the adsorption of O2. The new peak at 2123 cm–1 can be attributed to the vibration mode of CO bonded on Pdσ+, which represents partially oxidized Pd formed via the pre-adsorption of O2 [45, 46]. Interestingly, the peak at 2123 cm-1 was not observed for pure Pd. It has been demonstrated that CO could not be adsorbed on bulk PdO at room temperature [47, 48]. In comparison with the samples without pretreatment, the O2-pretreated Pd50Sb and Pd20Sb catalysts showed a reduction in the intensities of the linearly bonded CO; thus, we deduce that O2 prefers to adsorb at the corner or edge sites of Pd. Moreover, from the change in the vibration mode of CO on contiguous ensembles, it can be inferred that O2 also existed on the plane sites of Pd particles. Thus, in comparison with the Pd-alone catalyst, the highly reactive sites for O2 dissociation at the corner or edge of Pd-Sb catalysts were significantly deactivated by pre-adsorbed O2, and the interaction between molecular O2 and Pd-Sb catalysts weakened remarkably. Therefore, the addition of Sb is beneficial for the selective activation of O2 and subsequent H2O2 synthesis.
Sb has been proved to be inert for the activation of H2 [36]. Therefore, the presence of Sb was expected to suppress H2 adsorption. Accordingly, H2-TPD was conducted for all Pd-Sb/TiO2 and Pd-alone catalysts (Fig. 8). For the Pd-alone sample, two peaks at 741 and 794 K were observed at room temperature. The peak at 794 K can be assigned to H2 from the recombination and desorption of sub-surface hydrogen species upon heating, and the one at 741 K can be attributed to the surface hydrogen species weakly bonded to the surface in the presence of sub-surface hydrogen species. Due to their small sizes in contrast to Pd crystals, hydrogen atoms can deeply migrate into the bulk far away from the surface, and thus, the sub-surface hydrogen species are available for the reaction. Upon heating the samples, surface hydrogen species were repopulated by the migration of hydrogen atoms from the sub-surface region [49-51]. With the increase in Sb loading, the peak shifted from 794 to 682 K gradually, and it disappeared completely for Pd2Sb, indicating that the dilution of the surface Pd atoms with Sb suppressed the H2 adsorption and dissociation. It explains the great suppression effect of Sb on the hydrogenation of H2O2.
The dissociative activation of O2 is generally accepted to lead to the side reactions over Pd-based catalysts. O2-TPD profiles (Fig. S1) showed that the activation of O2 weakened in the presence of Sb. No obvious O2 desorption was observed below 800 K. The peak at 930 K can be attributed to atomic oxygen resulting from the decomposition of PdOx [52-54]. With the increasing ratio of Sb/Pd, the atomic oxygen peak became weaker, owing to the weakness of O2 activation, suggesting that Sb species on the surface may inhibit the dissociative activation of O2 and oxidation of Pd. It agreed with the XPS results.
H2O2 is produced by the hydrogenation of molecular O2 on the Pd surface, whereas the sequential hydrogenation of H2O2 and the O–O bond rupture of surface species would lead to the formation of H2O [55]. Tian et al. [56] has reported that the higher binding energy of O–O-containing surface species are not favorable for H2O2 synthesis because the higher BE results in lower dissociation barriers. The selectivity toward H2O2 is therefore mainly determined by the competition between O-H bond formation and O–O bond cleavage reactions of species containing O–O bonds. Density-functional theory (DFT) calculations demonstrated that low-coordinated Pd monomers embedded in Au sites were energetically unfavorable for the dissociation of O2 with a relative lower desorption (< 0.48 eV) and higher dissociation barrier (> 1.17 eV) than that of contiguous Pd ensembles [57]. Potentially, the isolated Pd sites, on which the O–O bonds are more difficult to rupture, match the requirement of H2O2 formation better. In this work, Pd upon alloying with Sb can significantly enhance the H2O2 selectivity. To better understand the effect of the Sb promoter, the characterization results were thoroughly analyzed and a plausible mechanism was proposed.
As measured by TEM and XRD, Pd-Sb catalysts showed smaller particle sizes and higher Pd dispersion than the monometallic Pd samples. Hutchings et al. [58] reported that reducing the size of the Pd NPs led to more exposed Pd atoms and enhanced the activation of H2 and O2. However, Pd-Sb catalysts in this work exhibited lower activity than monometallic Pd, and the catalysts with higher Sb/Pd ratios (> 0.5) were inert for the formation of H2O2. It can be inferred that the incorporation of Sb remarkably changed the surface state of the Pd NPs. XPS results have proved that the surfaces of Pd-Sb catalysts were partially covered by Sb2O3 layers. In this case, few contiguous Pd ensembles are exposed to H2 and O2, retarding the activation of H2 and O2 and suppressing the catalyst activity. The BEs of the Pd 3d core levels had a blue-shift of ca. 0.1–0.3 eV, indicating weak electronic interaction between Sb and Pd. A similar shift was also reported in the Pt-Sb systems [59]. In addition, the ratio of Pd0/Pd2+ on the particle surface increased with an increase in the Sb concentration. Sb might inhibit the oxidation of Pd and weaken the metal-support interaction.
In situ DRIFT spectra revealed that the CO vibration mode over the fresh catalysts experienced an obvious change with the addition of Sb. The fraction of the linear CO bands increased with the higher Sb loadings, indicating that Sb can generate more isolated Pd sites and reduce the contiguous Pd ensembles on the surface. Therefore, the non-dissociative activation of molecularly adsorbed O2 is pivotal for this reaction. Previous results have confirmed that isolated Pd sites surrounded by less active metal atoms showed lower activity for the dissociation of O–O bonds, and they were more favorable for H2O2 formation than contiguous Pd ensembles [60]. Therefore, the higher H2O2 selectivity over Pd-Sb bimetallic catalysts could be attributed to the isolation effect of active Pd atoms by Sb. In contrast, the reason why the isolated Pd sites are unfavorable for the O–O bond rupture is not yet clear for the reaction. Accordingly, in situ CO-DRIFTS over the Pd-Sb/TiO2 pretreated with O2 was performed to simulate the O2-rich environment in the reaction. Tian et al. [56] demonstrated that the addition of Te led to an increase in the low-coordinated active sites at the corner and edge sites, which are much more active for the undesired production of H2O[23]. The appearance of surface Pdσ+ species and the reduction of linearly bonded CO with the addition of Sb suggest that these low-coordinated active sites were partially oxidized by the O2 pretreatment, and their activities for O–O bond scission reactions were suppressed. As a result, the H2O2 selectivities for the Pd-Sb catalysts were enhanced.
As evidenced by TPD results, the addition of Sb suppressed the adsorption and dissociation of H2 and O2 over Pd catalysts, resulting in lower H2 conversions and higher H2O2 selectivities. Obviously, Sb hindered the hydrogenation and decomposition of H2O2 primarily by weakening the activation of H2 on Pd. The weak adsorption of O2 at the Pd-Sb/TiO2 interface is proposed to enhance the selectivity of H2O2.
In summary, the catalyst structures were characterized using multiple techniques to identify the origin of active sites responsible for the observed high selectivity. The role of Sb on the active sites of Pd catalysts was investigated by: (1) isolating contiguous Pd sites via the formation of Pd-Sb bimetallic sites, (2) coating Pd surface via the formation of Sb2O3 layer, and (3) promoting the formation of Pdσ+ species located on the surface during the reaction. Therefore, an optimum Pd/Sb ratio should be finely tuned to obtain the best performance. A plausible mechanism for H2O2 synthesis was proposed as illustrated in Scheme 1. With the addition of Sb, Pd-Sb bimetallic sites were formed and Pd NPs were diluted, leading to the reduction of the Pd particle size. The isolated Pd sites surrounding by Sb are responsible for the non-dissociative activation of O2 and selective synthesis of H2O2. In contrast, the contiguous Pd ensembles are more favorable for H2O formation because of their high activatity for the O–O rupture reactions. Sb, which is supposed to be concentrated on the catalyst surfaces, inhibited H2 adsorption and decreased the activity of H2O2 hydrogenation. However, due to the limitations of in situ characterizations in the tri-phase liquid system, the dynamic structures of Pd catalysts during the reaction and the mechanism of the effects of Pdσ+ species on the catalytic performance should be further investigated.
In this work, direct H2O2 synthesis from H2 and O2 has been studied using a series of bimetallic Pd-Sb/TiO2 catalysts with different Pd/Sb ratios, among which the Pd50Sb catalyst exhibited the best performance with the H2O2 selectivity of 73%. H2O2 hydrogenation rates decreased rapidly with the increase in the Sb/Pd ratios. Multiple characterization results indicated that the electronic and geometric structures of Pd-Sb catalysts were finely tuned with the Sb concentrations. In situ CO-DRIFT, XPS, and H2-TPD results proved that the increase in Sb concentration led to an increase in the ratio of isolated Pd sites that are assumed to be less active for side reactions and more favorable for H2O2 formation. In the meantime, the amount of contiguous Pd ensemble sites that are highly reactive for H2O2 hydrogenation were reduced, thus improving the selectivity. In summary, through adding a second nonprecious metal Sb to Pd, the highly selective Pd-based bimetallic catalysts were obtained for H2O2 synthesis. Deep insight into the effect of Sb on Pd particles will have more implications for the understanding of the mechanism and rational design of Pd catalysts for H2O2 synthesis.